“These Are The Arguments Put Forward By ChatGPT!” Advertising Week APAC’s Fiery AI Debate
The first day of festivities at Advertising Week APAC wrapped up with a fiery debate about whether AI will cause the public to mistrust advertising.
Lead image L-R: Arushi Srivastava, manager, client services, Cashrewards; Rebecca Reid
activations manager, Admatic; Courtney Mitchell, sales executive, FlashTalking by Mediaocean; Orsolya Toth-Pal, founder, Debate Club; Sophie Gallagher, senior strategist, Slingshot; Andrew Mo, digital producer, Yahoo; Aimee Jenkins, senior platform strategy lead, Yahoo.
“The affirmative has missed one very key point today and that is the question itself… I’m sorry to say that this question we’re debating today is fundamentally incorrect because there already is endemic mistrust in advertising and there has been for a very long before AI was in the picture,” said Sophie Gallagher, creative strategy director at Slingshot.
However, Courtney Mitchell, sales executive at FlashTalking by Mediaocean, speaking for the affirmative team set the terms of the debate clearly.
“We’re here to talk about what will happen when the line becomes blurred between us using AI as a tool and AI using us as its tool. Think about the endless possibilities of AI in advertising as it continues to advance,” she said.
“You can see yourself, your friends and your families CGI-ed [sic] into an ad which is showing a product or service that you have never heard of or seen. How could you trust that?”
She went on to explain how it was “so daunting” that McDonald’s is “reportedly working on a new AI tech” that will pump ads “into your dreams when you’re at your most vulnerable.”
“It will cause us as consumers to continually question everything we see,” she said.
However, Andrew Mo, digital producer at Yahoo, said that the concerns expressed by the affirmative team were not only irrelevant but unoriginal.
“They’re arguing that there is an invasion of privacy with AI, there are new kinds of advertising practices with AI and there is a lack of transparency with AI, he said.
“I expected these arguments because these are also the arguments put forward when I typed the debate topic into ChatGPT!”
He continued by saying that in order to prevent invasions of privacy, a “comprehensive policy” that outlines what data is collected, how it’s used and who has access to it. A consent model could also be created to allow users to opt in, as could ethical guidelines.
The Opposing team were performing brilliantly but Arushi Srivastava, manager, client services at Cashrewards, took to the stage and stole the show.
“My wonderful opponents shared with you this beautiful example of Nestle leveraging blockchain technology to create this product that demonstrated sustainability and build trust,” she said.
“But are we talking about product development or advertising? Nestle is going to need to tell their consumers that they have solved sustainability.”
Then, Srivastava took aim at Google, explaining how its Performance Max product allowed advertisers to create a landing page for a website while it generates keywords, descriptions, and content and it instructs the company where it should advertise its products.
“Wait, hold on, what’s actually happening with Google? They’re in the news because there was fraud in 80 per cent of YouTube ads that leveraged AI technology. It’s reaching incorrect consumers,” she explained.
“They have ads for Johnson & Johnson — would that be Nestle? — and American Express on sites that spread misinformation… How will that cause mistrust? Because machines and AI are built on the datasets that you give them today. Trust doesn’t have a fundamental framework that you can build into AI.”
Gallagher took to the stage again to show that, actually, AI can do good for the world. She explained how the “Unfair” campaign from Samsung Spain used AI to help people on the autism spectrum feel comfortable in loud spaces by creating an app that works with its earbuds to dampen the volume of triggering sounds.
“AI, backed by humanity, helps to facilitate connection and connection generates trust,” she explained.
“We know that every single day, we use AI with humanity it is incredibly powerful. We have shown that AI won’t lead to mistrust in advertising because there already is. But it does have the potential to build greater trust in advertising by elevating our humanity.”
The judging panel, which consisted of Colin Barnard, MD at Criteo; Denny Handlin, head of global business marketing at TikTok; Gai Le Roy, CEO of IAB Australia; Greg ‘Sparrow’ Graham; and Paul Conyngham, co-founder, Core Intelligence Technologies found that the Opposing team and its arguments around mistrust already existing in advertising more convincing.
The audience, meanwhile, was not quite so taken with the Opposing team’s focus on semantics and named the Affirmative team as the winner.
Please login with linkedin to comment
Advertising Week APACLatest News
Indie Agency Communicado Raids Thinkerbell For Its Two New Associate Creative Directors
Thinkerbell duo depart for rival agency Communicado. Leaving speeches were said to be convivial but restrained.
“Utterly Irresponsible” Sportsbet Slammed For Near-$20m Marketing Blitz As Gambling Ban Approaches
Sportsbet has been slammed as “utterly irresponsible” after a $19.4 million marketing blitz that, in the eyes of one anti-gambling advocate should “destroy their social licence to operate.” Tim Costello chief advocate of the Alliance for Gambling Reform said that “This proves a levy on Sportsbet is appropriate and why are we allowing our kids […]
Casella Appoints Dig As Creative Agency On Yellow Tail Wine
There's three givens at B&T's Friday staff drinks - the Yellow Tail, the Cheezels and the incessant bickering.
Seven Prioritises The Matildas Over The News AND The AFL In Extraordinary Decision Ahead Of The Women’s World Cup Quarter Final
Scott and Charlene's wedding now under serious threat as Saturday's Matilda's game threatens to smash all TV records.
News Corp Earnings Down Across The Board Despite Jump In Subscribers
Rupert can't find a coin for his ALDI trolley as News Corp earnings drop calls for renewed round of belt tightening.
Despite The Outrage & The Bans, The Sports Bet Category Remains Adland’s Zaniest (See This!)
The Guardian may no longer be running sports bet advertising, but as you'll read here, B&T has far less morals & ethics.
Last Chance To Buy Tickets For This Year’s B&T Women In Media Awards!
B&T's not giving away too many secrets to the Women In Media Awards suffice to say two words - chocolate and fountain.
The Trade Desk, Magnite & LiveRamp Deliver Growth, PubMatic Flat In Q2 Earnings
B&T's calling this your Q2 earnings wrap. We even considered wheeling out "must read" to help it along a bit.
Cinema Chain Spoofs Classic Movies In Wonderfully Funny Work To Entice People Back Into Theatres
Call it the Barbenheimer effect, but cinema's suddenly cool again. Yet, absolutely no uptick whatsoever for drive-ins.
Mediabrands Launches Internship Program For Aspiring Media Professionals
Mediabrands are on the lookout for young, enthusiastic go-getters for its internship program. But then, aren't we all?
Nike Celebrates The Matildas & Young Aussie Female Athletes In New Work By Conscious Minds
In what can be best described as a rare treat, it's a localised Nike ad. Kinda like finding the milk's not out of date.
Why Your CX Technology Should Focus On Connections
This expert opines it's not about your newfangled tech stacks, it's about your customers. Even the ones you detest.
WPP & Optimizely Partner To Bring Informed Digital Experiences To Brands & Consumers
Often think WPP's a 'canary in the coal mine' for industry trends? Well, avoid the black lung reading this latest.
Dylan Alcott & Hnry Team Up To Relieve Aussie Sole Traders Of Scary Tax Admin
Can the effervescent Dylan Alcott make tax admin even remotely interesting? Watch as he gives his best shot here.
D&AD Shift With Google Sydney Announce Class Of 2023
Need to poach some hot young agency talent? Poach away here, but just don't rat on B&T for the heads up.
Digital Media Agency Bench Rebrands To The Digital Disruption Agency
You could say Bench has been benched, as agency rebrands to the Digital Disruption Agency.
Seven Appoints Indie Creative Agency Emotive To Reshape Broadcaster’s Brand
Seven planning a brand zjoosh and spring clean. Although the offical corporate red and the number 7 is off limits.
Elon Musk Says The ABC Prefers “Censorship-Friendly” Social Media
It appears the ABC's found a new enemy in Elon Musk. However, News Corp remains entrenched at the top of the enemy list.
Wednesday TV Ratings: The Chase Just Beats The Block To Entertainment Win
Nine wins Wednesday night. However, Seven tells rival you'll get that and more come Saturday's Matilda's match.
B&T’s Best Of The Best Technologists, Presented By Finecast, Part Of GroupM Nexus
Somewhat ironically, this top 10 technologists list wasn't written with any help from ChatGPT or AI whatsoever!
Former Woman’s Day Editor Fiona Connolly Appointed Head of News’ Lifestyle Network
You could say ink runs in the veins of women's magazine veteran Fiona Connolly. And sponge cake recipes.
X Adds Brand Safety Tools In Bid To Bring Back Ad Dollars
Elon back contemplating the colonisation of Mars after finding this whole Twitter thing one huge headache.
ACMA Rules Kyle Sandilands’ Monkeypox Comments Breached Decency Rules And Were Offensive To Gay Men
Watchdog rules Kyle offended gay men. Punishment includes listening to Barbra Streisand & Céline Dion CDs on repeat.
Ozzy Osborne Bites Off More Than He Can Chew With Banned PlayStation Ad
Ozzy Osborne continuing to surprise. No more so than the fact that he's actually still alive and kicking.
Swisse Wellness Wheels In the Celebs To Stop Late Night Doom Scrollers
Is your sleep routine two Quaaludes and a swig from the sherry bottle? There's tips here for a more blissful night.
“All Good Things Must Come To An End, Well This One Barely Got started!” Jerker Fagerström Quits Thinkerbell After Eight Months
Thinkerbell fridge sans all smörgåstårta & pickled herring as Jerker Fagerström heads for the utgång (exits).
Footballing God Cristiano Ronaldo Bumbles His Way through New Work For Fan App Zuju
This ad proves Cristiano Ronaldo is just one of the guys. Just a filthy rich one of the guys, that is.
Samsung Ads’ Marj Hetherton On Why CTV Is The Most Exciting Area Of Advertising
Samsung Ads' Marj Hetherton says CTV is the most exciting area of advertising. That and nine-hour client lunches.
CommBank Matildas REMOVES Tim Tam TikTok Following B&T Story
If Tim Tam's marketing team wants to send B&T some freebies for this free press we'll take any flavour but mint or dark.
Tinder’s New Global Campaign Says Online Dating Need Not Be An Unrivalled Hell
If there were truth in advertising, these spots would feature a drunk bloke with poor hygiene who lives with his mother.
ADMA Adds New Speakers For Upcoming Global Forum
ADMA confirms speaker line-up for upcoming Global Forum. Also, 300 arancini balls locked-in for the networking drinks.
IMAA Census Predicts Growth In BVOD/CTV, Digital Video And Podcasts
The IMAA census is like a finger on the pulse of Australia's adland. And we all need a solid finger now and then.
Prestige Brands Targets Gen Z With Racy Billie Eilish Perfume Ad Via Spark Foundry
Billie Eilish the latest celeb to release a fragrance. Meanwhile, B&T still waiting on an Angus Young eau de toilette.
The Australian Women’s Weekly Celebrates Its 90th Birthday
The Weekly celebrates its 90 birthday. B&T believes the first-ever copy is still in our GP's reception.
Connecting Plots Delivers Latest Iteration Of “The Experts In Air” For Mitsubishi Air-Conditioners
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Air-Conditioners Australia (MHIAA) has launched its latest campaign via Connecting Plots drawing subtle similarities to the world of wine sommeliers. In a highly competitive category that’s hard to navigate, the new campaign by Connecting Plots seeks to unlock the assurance of an expert opinion, with the MHIAA Air Experts behaving like wine […]
Delicious Partners With Harvey Norman For 2023 Produce Awards
The Royal Easter Show not the only place to see the very best in pumpkins, as Delicious announces annual produce awards.